Dr. Katherine Craig Ma

Thank you Dr. Ma for your 7 months of no help whatsoever. You discriminated my age and sent me to PT with a broken foot. Only when Dr. Kelmanovich saw me he immediately put a cast on and took a CT scan. Not only one break but 2. Had to have surgery and now have a plate and screws in my foot and a bone taken from my heel to replace the broken bone. I am so disappointed in your professional help. May will be a year for me. And you wasted it on calling out my age for not healing. As a professional that was totally wrong on your part. Not putting a cast was a fault and not taking me seriously was wrong. I've never been so angry and upset with a Dr. As much as I am with you hopefully this tells you something when other patients even consider you. Deborah jones o'leary

Thank you, Dr. Katherine Ma for the surgeries you performed, your clear explanations and patience with my questions. I am thrilled to be back in shoes and looking forward to going hiking!

Dr. Ma and her staff are excellent! She is knowledgeable, considerate, and thorough. I am so thankful her services are close to home.

Dr. Ma is very knowledgeable and honest. She is very easy to talk to and will explain anything you want/need to know in detail. When I re-broke the same ankle (why...) I was terrified it would never heal properly, but she took care of me and it healed pretty quickly. The staff was also very good and eager to help as well.

Doctor Ma is an excellent Physician & Surgeon. I had experienced extreme pain & discomfort on my right foot. I had seen several other Physicians in the area but found Doctor Ma to be by far the most earnest & forthright regarding my options. I personally found Doctor Ma's approach to be the most sincere & clear for me. In February Doctor Ma operated on my foot with her extremely loyal & skilled team. The outcome for me has been very successful. Caremount Medical should be very proud to have someone of Doctor Ma's caliber on staff. If you require orthopedic surgery I would strongly recommend Doctor Ma & her fabulous team. Thank you

Highly recommend her. Easy to talk to, attentive. Followed up after my surgery to check in on me.

Never. She did not seem to understand the issue and offered no help to improve my situation. She simply said it is what it is and will reconcile or not. I found her totally not helpful and felt she did not understand her field.

Dr. Ma is very engaging and she was able to ease my discomfort by listening. She was understanding and I would highly recommend her. She is professional and excellent at her craft. My surgery went very well.

I agree with another reviewer. She was cold and definitely condescending to my elderly mom and myself. Never recommend only to stay away

I had emergency surgery with Dr Ma. Her care was excellent from the start. She is a very compassionate, down to earth professional. And I would highly recommend her and Northern Westchester Hospital.

Cold, condescending, and dismissive. She spent 5 minutes with me, didn’t take the time to read the form I filled out in detail, pertaining to my history, didn’t even have x-rays taken (when there’s a radiology department in the building), or give me specific stretches to do after she told me, “You’re just really tight.” “So, why are you here to see me when you’re seeing all these other doctors? (with a smug face).” Wow, Dr. Ma. That’s a great question why I chose to see you. I wish I hadn’t inconvenienced myself or you, for that matter, seeing as you seemed to be in such a rush. I have never written a bad review for a doctor in my life until today.

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

We used Dr. Ma for my daughter's follow up visit. She was so nice and very informative. She took the time to make sure I knew what the x-rays were showing, I understood her advice and that my daughter was not scared. She really knew how to interact with a young child and made the entire experience so easy.

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

I recently broke my angle & had the extreme good fortune to have Dr. Ma provide me her expertise. I found her to not only be down to earth, but also compassionate, & very knowledgeable beyond her years. simply a wonderful "human being". As one of my favorite poets once wrote. He who learns must suffer & even in my sleep, pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, & in are own despair, against our will, comes wisdom through the awful grace of God.... that poem is for you Dr.

Stay away at all cost. She did speak to me or my family after surgery. She gave me one prescription for pain before surgery and that was it I also couldn’t speak with her. She communicated through an assistant. Terrible experience. I hope I can find another dr for follow up care. Worst experience with any dr my entire life with myself or family. I am totally disgusted, disappointed, and furious.

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review

Dr. Ma seen our son after breaking his foot and couldn't have chosen a better doctor. She is knowledgeable, kind,and explains everything perfectly which makes it easy to understand. Kathy her assistant is amazing as well and they both make a great team. On short notice they were able to get us in, treat my son and can't thank them enough for this.

Front desk are useless and extremely rude. Doctor is not patient oriented, lack of patient care, compassion, 5 minutes in the room, don't know if she really listen to any of patient concerns. Will never recommend her to anybody.

Dr. Ma is a kind and caring doctor. She spent a lot of time with my, explaining my surgery. She understands what it is like to be a scared patient. Her surgery results are excellent. I feel so much better!

I just want to say that Dr. Ma and her nurse Kathy are a great team and I would recommend them. Knowledgeable along with great bedside manner's. They answered all of my questions and continue to do so.

This user rated the provider, but did not write a review